Sometimes it’s actually that bad.

We thought we were special. We thought a Holmes nerd could glean something worth talking about from a movie that didn’t just get trashed but buried under a mountain of sludge. We were extremely wrong.

CONTENT WARNING for discussion of misogyny and fatphobia.

1:00 Mistakes Were Made
3:00 Sherlockian Lineage
14:00 What Is Plot
32:30 Why is This Dead Lady Here
40:00 Should You Watch This

Say hi to Dorothy and Vrai on Twitter @writervrai and @dorothynotgale

Our icon was designed by Allison Shabet.

Get bonus episodes on our Patreon

Join us every two weeks on Soundcloud, iTunes or Stitcher – and if you’d leave a rating and review, so that more people can find their way to us, we’d appreciate it!